|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
[SPECIAL JANUARY PROMOTION: Spend $50+ In The FPM Store And Receive A Free Copy Of “Final Battle” By David Horowitz.]
Antisemitism on American college campuses is not new. College presidents and professors didn’t begin tolerating or teaching antisemitism last Oct. 8. Students marching on behalf of the annihilation of the Jewish state, student activists tearing down posters of kidnapped Jewish children, locking Jewish students in a library at Cooper Union and “70% of Jewish college students feeling forced to hide their Jewish identities” are the result of decades of anti-Israel, anti-Zionist and anti-Jewish rhetoric.
One example I recently came across is a column titled “When Young Jews Major in Antisemitism,” published in 2005 in the Los Angeles Times. When I looked to see who wrote the column, I saw — to my surprise — that I did. I did not recall writing the piece. But it is very much worth reading today.
“American Jewry is experiencing a cognitive dissonance the likes of which it has never known. To illustrate, consider my recent lecture in Virginia Beach, Va.: ‘Antisemitism at the Universities: What Can We Do About It?’
“It is very significant that a mainstream (i.e., largely secular and liberal) Jewish organization (the Jewish Community Center) would fly a speaker from across the country to speak on anti-Semitism at universities…
“Universities have become society’s primary breeding ground for hatred of Israel. This hatred is often so intense that the college campus has become a haven for people who use anti-Zionism to mask their anti-Semitism. Moreover, anti-Zionism itself is a form of antisemitism, even if some Jews share it. Why? Because anti-Zionism is not simply criticism of Israel, which is as legitimate as criticism of any country. Anti-Zionism means that Israel as a Jewish state has no right to exist. And when a person argues that only one country in the world is unworthy of existence — and that happens to be the one Jewish country in the world — one is engaged in antisemitism, whether personally antisemitic or not.
“Not long ago, on my radio show, I invited a UCLA student who, on the occasion of Israel’s birthday, had written a hate-filled article about the Jewish state in the Bruin, the school newspaper. I asked her if she had always been anti-Israel. She said that as a Jewish girl growing up in Britain, she was actually a Zionist who had visited Israel a number of times on Jewish student trips there.
“‘What changed you?’ I asked.
“‘The university,’ she responded.
“That sort of transformation may be what inspired Harvard University’s president, Lawrence Summers, to deliver a speech in which he identified the university as replacing the far right as a center of antisemitism. ‘Where antisemitism and views that are profoundly anti-Israeli have traditionally been the primary preserve of poorly educated right-wing populists,’ he warned, ‘profoundly anti-Israel views are increasingly finding support in progressive intellectual communities. Serious and thoughtful people are advocating and taking actions that are anti-Semitic in their effect if not their intent.’
“The vast majority of pro-Israel Jews, secular and religious, liberal and conservative, know this. That explains the lecture topic I was asked to speak about in Virginia to a largely secular and liberal Jewish audience.
“To make matters worse for many Jews’ psyches, not only has the institution they most revere turned out to be a moral wasteland and the most congenial place for enemies of the Jewish people — and of the United States (but that is another story) — at the same time, the people whom many Jews have most feared, conservative Christians, have turned out to be the Jews’ most loyal friends. That the secular university is bad for Jews, and conservative Christians are good for Jews, is more than enough cognitive dissonance for a Jew to experience in a lifetime.”
Two reflections on what I wrote 19 years ago:
First, neither I nor any description of the universities as “moral wastelands” would be printed in the Los Angeles Times today. The Los Angeles Times was liberal for at least 60 years — the last Republican presidential candidate the paper endorsed was Dwight Eisenhower in 1956 — but it is now leftist. Its editorial and opinion pages went from liberal, which meant that I and other conservatives could often be published, to left-wing and woke boilerplate. The level of its editorials and columnists is as low intellectually as it is morally. One of these columnists actually wrote that Larry Elder, one of the most brilliant conservative minds in America today, is “the black face of white supremacy.” The fools who run the Los Angeles Times are consigning the paper to a fate similar to that of Sports Illustrated. “SI,” as it was known to sports fans, was once the country’s most revered sports magazine. Then, like the L.A. Times, it went woke. Soon it will be no longer.
Second, the deterioration of Harvard is also reflected in my column of 19 years ago. I quoted Harvard’s then-president, Lawrence Summers, who decried the Israel-hating, leading-to-antisemitism views of “progressive intellectual communities.” From Larry Summers to Claudine Gay, Harvard’s moral decline perfectly mirrors that of Sports Illustrated and the Los Angeles Times. Everything the Left touches, it destroys.
And sadly many Jewish intellectuals were at the forefront of this movement. Hard to understand why so many Jews became leftists and still vote for democrats upwards of 70%
I’m sure that if Peter Beinert, Thomas Friedman, Noam Chomsky and Norman Finkelstein had been adults in Nazi occupied Europe,they’d have outdone Chaim Rumkowski or Stella Goldschlag as self hating Jews. Certainly Soros managed to cover himself in infamy as a 14 year old delivering deportation notices and confiscating Jewish property in Budapest in 1944, during what he calls “The happiest period of my life”
There is a self-loathing strain that runs through Judaism. Whether one deems that to be a form of white guilt, effeminate empathy, or what – it’s there.
Could be Stockholm Syndrome. They have been downtrodden, demonized and destroyed for 2,000 years so they have to be terribly affected deep down in their psyche.
It’s hard not to see Jewish self-loathing, however deplorable, as being anything but a reflection and a result of the hatred and loathing that Jews have experienced for thousands of years.. I see it as an internalisation of that as well as a rather despicable desire to be liked and feel safe among the virtue signalling great and good of society- which doesn’t actually work.
Even self loathing Jews experience antisemitism, turning against your fellow Jews may buy you some time but the bigots and haters will still come for you.. Islamists and Leftists and Nazis don’t care if you attend Pride, or denounce Israel, or recire Kaddish for Hamas- in their eyes, you may be useful for a while but you are still a Jew.
The 1960s/1970s turmoil inflicted on America by the New and Old Left has been romanticized in so many ways by so many people as to have become an irresistable model for college professors and students. Their urge to wreck society as flamboyantly as possible needed a focus, so they chose the latest craze of hating Israel and Jews.
“Today, campuses are primary breeding grounds for hatred of Israel and Jews.”…………. AND CHRISTIANS
But also left-wing academe has become weirdly accommodating in its attitude towards Islam and religious Muslims. They don’t realize that the Green-Red Islamic-leftist alliance is merely tactical as the Muslims are strategic enemies of the left..
Even as a kid and before I had any awareness of world affairs and politics, I could never understand the widespread, profound and visceral hatred for Jews. Nor did I understand (and I still don’t) why so many people believe Israel has no right to exist. I remember feeling sick to my stomach the first time I heard about the Holocaust and couldn’t imagine such evil existed.
I grew up in a neighbourhood among Italian, Portuguese and Polish families. My first job as a cashier in a supermarket took me through high school. The owners were Jewish and some of the best bosses I ever had.
I found out much after the fact that my healthcare providers – dentist, GP and gynecologist were all Jewish. Not that it mattered – I had profound respect for their professionalism and their commitment to their patients’ well-being. One of them continued to take care of me when I couldn’t afford to pay for provincial healthcare (that was back in the 70s when I was a very poor student subsisting on student loans). He lived by his Hippocratic oath and told me to never stop consulting him because of lack of finances.
This millennia-old anti-Semitism will likely never die and it is truly a tragedy.
Its past time to totally defund these Universities by 100% Lets use the Money for a Effective Border Wall and Housing our vets being evicted to make room for Migrants by the Liberal Democrat/Globalists
We did not subscribe to your college thesis tome. Truncate your posts, please.
Jordan, which wasn’t yet in existence had little to do with Jabotinsky’s thinking. As a leader of the Jewish Legion who fought with the British, he supported then felt betrayed. It didn’t help when the Brits arrested him, put him on trial, then sentenced him to 15 years.
In view of events, don’t you think he may have modified his views.?
There’s only one person who can help.
Everyone knows. Most will fail.